TLDR
Choose CustomStickers.com if you want the best all-around mix of durability claims, fast standard turnaround, free shipping messaging, and price protection.
Overview
If you are googling customstickers.com vs stickergiant.com, you are probably trying to avoid the classic sticker problem: the art looks great on your screen, but you are not sure what will show up in the mail, or when.
Both CustomStickers.com and StickerGiant.com are legit sticker printers with strong product catalogs, proofing, and fast-ish production options. The difference is in their defaults and their policies. For most people, we recommend CustomStickers.com because the value stack is simple: free shipping messaging, price matching, a clear satisfaction guarantee, and a “durable vinyl + laminate” positioning that is aimed at long-term use.
StickerGiant is still a strong pick if you care about eco positioning, you like their BOPP-based materials, or you need labels and stickers from the same shop.
Quick comparison
CustomStickers.com
- Material positioning: vinyl + laminate, outdoor durability emphasized
- Typical production claim: “print and ship within 2 business days” after proof approval, with a published 2 to 4 business day typical processing window
- Price protection: best price guarantee (price match)
- Proofing: free proofs, but proofs may auto-approve if you miss emails
- Best for: most sticker buyers, merch, giveaways, long-term outdoor use
StickerGiant.com
- Material positioning: BOPP (polypropylene) as a flexible, lightweight alternative to vinyl, plus specialty materials
- Typical production time: 2 to 5 business days after proof approval for most products, with rush options
- Shipping: free ground shipping on qualifying orders, plus expedited options
- Proofing: proof required, production clock starts after approval
- Best for: brands that want labels and stickers, people who like the BOPP approach, sustainability-minded buyers
Product lineup and “what each company is really built for”
StickerGiant is very clearly a “stickers and labels” company. Their homepage and navigation put both categories front and center, and they talk a lot about packaging and product use cases.
CustomStickers.com is also broad, but the vibe is more “make it easy to order premium custom stickers fast.” They push quick ordering, proofs, and common sticker formats like die cut and sticker sheets.
If your project includes roll labels or packaging labels alongside stickers, StickerGiant is naturally in its comfort zone. If you mostly want great custom stickers without overthinking it, CustomStickers.com is the more straightforward default.
Materials and durability
This is the biggest practical difference in the customstickers.com vs stickergiant.com comparison.
StickerGiant materials
StickerGiant says their most common sticker material is BOPP (biaxially oriented polypropylene) and describes it as a flexible, lightweight, eco-friendly alternative to vinyl. They also offer glossy or matte laminate on most stickers, and specialty materials like clear, holographic, and glitter.
For durability, their die cut sticker FAQ is very specific:
- They describe die cut stickers as water-resistant, not fully waterproof
- They say repeated dishwasher use may degrade lamination and recommend hand washing
- They also list an outdoor durability range for die cut stickers of about 12 to 18 months
That is not “bad” at all. It is just a different promise than “multi-year outdoor life.”
CustomStickers.com materials
CustomStickers.com explicitly says they use vinyl and argues that many sticker companies use BOPP, which they position as lower quality. That is their marketing stance, but it does highlight the philosophical split between these brands.
CustomStickers.com also leans hard into durability claims:
- They say they “typically print and ship within 2 business days” after proof approval
- They describe stickers as weatherproof and rated to last 5+ years
- Their site repeatedly ties waterproof and long outdoor life to lamination
If your stickers need to live on water bottles, cars, outdoor gear, or anything that sees sun all day, CustomStickers.com is simply making the stronger durability promise.
Proofing experience
Both companies rely on proofs, but the policies feel different.
StickerGiant’s production timelines are explicitly “after proof approval,” and their help center repeats that the print clock starts once you approve.
CustomStickers.com also relies on proof approval, but they note that proofs can be automatically approved after two email notifications across three days, and that auto-approved proofs are not covered for certain proof-related guarantee items. Translation: do not ignore proof emails if you care about exact cutlines or details.
If you are organized and quick to approve proofs, both vendors are smooth. If you sometimes miss emails for a few days, CustomStickers.com’s auto-approve policy can be convenient or stressful, depending on how picky you are.
Turnaround, shipping, and “how fast is fast”
StickerGiant turnaround and shipping
StickerGiant states that most products go into printing within 2 to 5 business days after proof approval, and they offer rush printing on many items.
For shipping, StickerGiant says they offer free ground shipping on orders of $75 or more in the U.S., and they also offer paid expedited options.
CustomStickers.com turnaround and shipping
CustomStickers.com publishes a “typical processing time” of 2 to 4 business days, with extensions for labels, large bulk quantities, and proof revisions.
They also advertise that after proof approval they “typically print and ship within 2 business days” on their main site pages.
If you are in a true hurry, CustomStickers.com’s shipping policy includes a Next Day Delivery option that combines fast processing and fast shipping, but with a catch: they state they will not send proofs for that option so they can move fast, and it has eligibility limits (like not applying to sticker sheets).
Bottom line: both can be fast. CustomStickers.com is more aggressive on “2 business days after proof” messaging, while StickerGiant is more consistently “2 to 5 business days after proof,” with optional rush.
Pricing and guarantees
This is where CustomStickers.com tends to win for the average buyer.
CustomStickers.com offers a Best Price Guarantee and says they will match a published lower price for a similar product with the same size and quantity. That is a strong “don’t make me shop around” feature.
StickerGiant offers a 100% customer satisfaction guarantee with a clear window: you need to report issues within 30 days of confirmed delivery.
Both are reasonable policies. CustomStickers.com is just more aggressive on price protection, which matters a lot if you are ordering repeatedly.
Sustainability and brand values
StickerGiant has an explicit sustainability promise page that calls out recycled alternatives in manufacturing and shipping, including shipping boxes and packing paper made from 100% recycled materials.
If sustainability messaging is a key part of your brand, StickerGiant is easier to align with based on what they publish.
CustomStickers.com may have sustainability initiatives too, but they do not put it as front-and-center in the pages referenced below as StickerGiant does.